A coexistence agreement is a contract in which two owners of similar marks accept each other's use within agreed limits. It can settle a dispute abroad, but whether a trademark office takes it into account differs from country to country.
The agreement usually draws lines. Each side keeps its mark for certain goods or services, in certain countries, and sometimes in a certain form, such as with a particular logo or colour. Each side also promises not to oppose or attack the other's registrations inside those lines. The clearer the lines, the less room there is for a new dispute later.
Two features of trademark law make such agreements workable. Rights are territorial, so the parties can divide markets country by country. And protection is tied to the list of goods and services in each registration, grouped in the 45 classes of the Nice Classification. A food brand in class 30 and a clothing brand in class 25 may find they can share a similar name comfortably.
There are limits to keep in mind. An agreement binds the two parties who sign it, not third parties. A trademark office may or may not accept it as an answer to an objection, depending on the country. And the list of goods cannot be widened after filing, so a promise to stay out of a field should match what each side really plans. Masar reviews the draft with the local agent in each country it touches.
Getting to a workable agreement
- 01
Map both sides' rights
Set out each party's registrations and filings by country and by class, with their dates.
- 02
Define the dividing lines
Agree which goods, services, countries and forms of the mark belong to each side.
- 03
Check it country by country
Masar asks the local agents how such an agreement is treated in each country concerned.
- 04
Align the registers
Where needed, limit or file applications so that what is registered matches what was agreed.
Frequently asked questions
Will a trademark office accept a coexistence agreement?
It depends on the country. Some offices take such agreements into account and others give them little weight, so Masar confirms the practice with the local agent before you rely on one.
Does a coexistence agreement cover all countries?
It covers the countries the parties write into it. Since registrations are national and independent, it is wise to state clearly which territories are included.