Intellectual Property
Copyright & software

Fair use is not a free pass: why a short clip is no defence

The length of a clip is one factor among four and does not settle the question alone. This page sets out the myth, the facts and a safe working rule for using third-party material.

Masar IP2 min read

"It was only a clip." That sentence is not a defence.

Many laws recognise fair use or fair dealing, weighing the purpose of the use, the nature of the work, the amount used and the effect on the potential market. US "fair use" weighs four factors (purpose, nature, amount and market effect) case by case, and "fair dealing" elsewhere is narrower still.

So the length of a clip is one factor among four, and it does not settle the question alone. For media and marketing teams, the safe working rule is to assume permission is needed until you have checked.

Myth vs fact

  1. 01

    Myth

    A short clip is always allowed

  2. 02

    Fact

    Purpose, nature, amount and market effect are weighed case by case

  3. 03

    Fact

    Fair dealing elsewhere is narrower still

  4. 04

    Rule of thumb

    Assume permission is needed until you have checked

MMasar Intellectual PropertyIraqi IP firm · Baghdad & Erbil