Patent or trade secret?
One famous beverage formula has stayed secret far longer than any patent could have lasted.
So should you always keep an invention secret? Not necessarily. A patent trades disclosure for a 20-year monopoly. A trade secret trades secrecy for potentially unlimited protection.
Patents require public disclosure of the invention in an official register. Trade secrets are not made public, so unlike patents they do not provide defensive protection as prior art; a later independent inventor can patent the same invention.
The right choice depends on whether your edge can be reverse-engineered.
Quick comparison
- 01
Patent
Public disclosure in an official register, a 20-year monopoly
- 02
Trade secret
Secrecy, with potentially unlimited protection
- 03
A trade secret does not stop a later independent inventor from patenting the same invention
- 04
Ask
Could others reverse-engineer our edge?
A trade secret is not a shield against copying
A secret formula is not a shield against copying.
Myth: a trade secret stops anyone from copying my product.
Fact: the owner of a trade secret cannot stop others who independently develop the same information, or who reverse engineer it or analyse the market.
This is why the choice between a patent and a secret matters. A patent trades disclosure for a 20-year monopoly. A trade secret trades secrecy for potentially unlimited protection, and one famous formula has stayed secret far longer than any patent could have lasted. The right choice depends on whether your edge can be reverse-engineered.
Ask yourself before you decide
- 01
Could a competitor work out how it is made by studying the product?
- 02
Could someone reach the same result on their own?
- 03
Is my advantage the kind that stays hidden once the product is sold?