Intellectual Property
Patents & designs

A patent appeal needs a detailed technical answer

A patent appeal is a technical argument, not a letter of protest. The inventors know the invention best, and the answer has to address every ground of rejection.

Masar IP2 min read

A patent appeal is a technical argument, not a letter of protest.

If a patent application is refused, the examiner's findings and grounds, such as lack of novelty or inventive step, are attached to the official refusal letter. Those grounds are exactly what an appeal has to answer.

A patent appeal needs a detailed technical response from the inventors, addressing each ground of rejection. A general statement that the invention is new does not engage with a specific ground. Detail does.

That is why the inventors should be involved from the moment the refusal letter arrives, not at the last minute. They know the invention best, and the technical answer has to come from them.

How to approach it

  1. 01

    Read the findings attached to the refusal letter carefully

  2. 02

    List each ground, for example lack of novelty or inventive step

  3. 03

    Bring the inventors in early

  4. 04

    Answer every ground in technical detail

MMasar Intellectual PropertyIraqi IP firm · Baghdad & Erbil