Intellectual Property
International IP

Patent versus trade secret: the question that decides your choice

Choosing between disclosure and secrecy is a strategic call. This page covers the catch on the secrecy side and why a later inventor can patent the same invention.

Masar IP2 min read
01

Two strategies, one deciding question

Twenty years of exclusivity, or protection that could last indefinitely: which would you choose?

Patent it, or keep it secret? A patent trades disclosure for a 20-year monopoly. A trade secret trades secrecy for potentially unlimited protection.

There is a catch on the secrecy side. Trade secrets are not made public, so unlike patents they do not provide defensive protection as prior art. A later independent inventor can patent the same invention.

So the right choice depends on whether your edge can be reverse-engineered.

A founder's comparison

  1. 01

    Patent

    Disclosure in exchange for a 20-year monopoly

  2. 02

    Trade secret

    Secrecy in exchange for potentially unlimited protection

  3. 03

    Trade secret risk

    No defence against a later independent patent on the same invention

  4. 04

    Deciding question

    Can your edge be reverse-engineered?

02

A trade secret is not a patent

A trade secret is not a patent kept in a drawer.

It is easy to assume that a trade secret protects an idea the way a patent does. The two work very differently.

A trade secret owner cannot stop others who independently develop the same information, or who reverse engineer or analyse the market. And because trade secrets are not made public, they do not provide defensive protection as prior art the way patents do. A later independent inventor can patent the same invention.

What this means for you

  1. 01

    Secrecy does not stop independent development.

  2. 02

    Secrecy does not stop reverse engineering or market analysis.

  3. 03

    A secret gives no prior-art defence if someone else patents the same invention later.

Before relying on secrecy alone, ask honestly how likely it is that someone could work out the same thing on their own.

MMasar Intellectual PropertyIraqi IP firm · Baghdad & Erbil